After seven and a half seasons in Formula 1, Charles Leclerc appears to have reached a crossroads at Ferrari. Not a technical one, because the performance of a Formula 1 car can change dramatically from one season to another, but a much harder obstacle for a driver to overcome: turning exceptional talent into leadership, consistency and the ability to manage a race when the pressure reaches its highest point.
Charles Leclerc’s talent has never seriously been questioned. If anything, that extraordinary natural ability is the starting point for almost everything that has defined his Ferrari career. Yet Sunday’s Italian Grand Prix at Monza offered another example of why talent alone may no longer be enough. The Monegasque displayed his speed and aggression, but once again failed to translate those qualities into the kind of race management expected from a driver of his level.
Charles Leclerc’s Ferrari story began with extraordinary promise
In 2019, during Charles Leclerc’s first season at Maranello, the driver on the other side of the Ferrari garage was four-time Formula 1 world champion Sebastian Vettel. Yet Charles Leclerc needed very little time to demonstrate that he was much more than simply a promising youngster.
Charles Leclerc finished fourth in the Drivers’ Championship with 264 points, seven pole positions, two victories and ten podium finishes. He even ended the year ahead of Sebastian Vettel, who scored 240 points. Charles Leclerc’s two victories came at Spa-Francorchamps and, most memorably, at Monza, where he claimed his first Italian Grand Prix victory in front of the Ferrari supporters.
It was exactly the sort of debut season many had expected from the talent who had impressed at Alfa Romeo Sauber. More importantly, however, it was still a debut from which nobody expected the finished product.
Charles Leclerc had entered Formula 1 with Sauber in 2018. His potential for growth appeared enormous, prompting Ferrari to accelerate its plans and bring him to Maranello as early as 2019. At that stage of his career, talent was enough.
The situation changed dramatically in 2020. Ferrari produced a car heavily affected by the consequences of the controversy surrounding its 2019 power unit and was nowhere near the performance level of the previous season. Despite that, Charles Leclerc again stood out. He scored 98 points compared with Sebastian Vettel’s 33, finishing eighth in the World Championship while the German ended the season 13th.
There were two podiums and no victories, but the performance difference inside the Ferrari garage was clear. Even then, however, nobody expected Charles Leclerc to already be a fully developed champion. He remained the young driver around whom Ferrari could build its future.
The Carlos Sainz years changed the challenge for Charles Leclerc
Then came 2021. Free from the presence of a four-time world champion such as Sebastian Vettel, Charles Leclerc finally had a clear opportunity to establish himself as Ferrari’s undisputed number-one reference point.
Ferrari placed Carlos Sainz alongside him, a driver from roughly the same generation, slightly older but still without a Formula 1 victory and apparently without the same level of natural talent generally attributed to Charles Leclerc.
On paper, it looked like the ideal situation. Charles Leclerc had extraordinary raw speed and a remarkable sensitivity over a single qualifying lap, qualities that had already helped him claim seven pole positions in 2019. Carlos Sainz, meanwhile, brought different strengths: relentless determination, an ability to construct his own results and, above all, an extremely strong personality.
That was where the first signs of a different challenge began to emerge.
In their first season together, Carlos Sainz finished ahead of Charles Leclerc in the Drivers’ Championship, scoring 164 points to the Monegasque driver’s 159. It was certainly not domination by the Spaniard, but it was the first indication that raw talent alone would not automatically transform Charles Leclerc into Ferrari’s unquestioned leader.
In the following seasons, Charles Leclerc often held the numerical advantage, particularly in 2022 and 2024. Yet his partnership with Carlos Sainz was also filled with difficult moments and confrontations both on and away from the circuit. Carlos Sainz continually applied pressure, responded when challenged and gradually built considerable influence of his own within Ferrari. The former Ferrari driver’s career and time alongside Charles Leclerc can also be followed through the Carlos Sainz archive.
And that is the key distinction. Charles Leclerc never really needed to prove that he was faster than Carlos Sainz. He needed to demonstrate that he was the driver around whom Ferrari should be built. Those are not the same thing.
Then Lewis Hamilton arrived at Ferrari
For that reason, Ferrari’s decision to sign Lewis Hamilton immediately raised another question. How could a driver who had never completely established himself as the undisputed authority within his own team against a team-mate such as Carlos Sainz expect to win the sporting and political battle against a seven-time Formula 1 world champion?
Lewis Hamilton is not simply an exceptionally fast racing driver. He has spent almost two decades learning exactly how Formula 1 works both on and off the circuit. Lewis Hamilton understands internal dynamics, communication and how to build support, while also knowing how to use the enormous media weight attached to his name.
He had already demonstrated that quality during his Formula 1 debut season in 2007, when his team-mate at McLaren was Fernando Alonso, then the reigning two-time world champion. Lewis Hamilton did not merely survive that comparison. He finished level with Fernando Alonso on 109 points and took the higher championship position on countback. Fernando Alonso then left McLaren at the end of the season.
Of course, it could be argued that McLaren was not entirely neutral towards its two drivers that year. Ron Dennis and Bernie Ecclestone probably recognised the enormous commercial and media opportunity represented by the young Lewis Hamilton. Winning the championship with a rookie, and particularly with the first driver of colour in Formula 1 history, would have carried extraordinary value for the image of the championship itself. It is an interpretation that cannot simply be ignored when analysing that season.
But that is precisely the point. Lewis Hamilton was sufficiently clever and strategically aware to make the most of a situation that was politically favourable to him. Nobody gifted him the talent required to compete with Fernando Alonso, just as nobody gave him the ability to transform external support into strength within the team. That ability was already part of his character.
It is no coincidence that several of Lewis Hamilton’s other team-mates have also found their relationship with him anything but straightforward. Nico Rosberg, once his friend, had to wage an uncompromising battle in 2016 to defeat Lewis Hamilton and become Formula 1 world champion.
Lewis Hamilton, in other words, has never merely been the driver who had to be beaten on the circuit. He has often also been the figure against whom team-mates had to compete in terms of personality, internal management and influence within a team. It is precisely this aspect that Charles Leclerc still appears not to have fully developed.
Did Lewis Hamilton’s difficult 2025 season mislead Charles Leclerc?
Lewis Hamilton’s first season with Ferrari may have contributed to a misleading impression. During 2025, Charles Leclerc looked like the natural reference point inside the team while Lewis Hamilton struggled to find consistency.
There were, however, very concrete reasons for those difficulties. It was Lewis Hamilton’s first season at Maranello after two decades spent almost entirely within British racing environments, involving different procedures, personnel, structures and working methods.
There was also the characteristics of the ground-effect Formula 1 cars introduced with the 2022 regulations, a generation of machinery that Lewis Hamilton had never truly enjoyed. The result was a season in which Charles Leclerc was often able to appear clearly superior to his new team-mate.
Lewis Hamilton, however, never appeared genuinely defeated.
The seven-time Formula 1 world champion had already demonstrated during his career that he could endure difficult periods without necessarily losing control of his position within a team. In 2025, Lewis Hamilton also made several extremely harsh public assessments of himself and was frequently very critical of his own performances.
Those who understood his career, however, could hardly have expected that version of Lewis Hamilton to be permanent. His 2026 results are beginning to demonstrate why.
Lewis Hamilton started producing important results and, gradually, his position inside Ferrari appeared to change. Recent reports have even raised questions over a possible shift in Lewis Hamilton’s influence within Ferrari and his relationship with team principal Fred Vasseur.
Charles Leclerc, by contrast, has combined some exceptional performances with difficult setbacks. By the time Formula 1 arrived at Monza, the internal situation was becoming increasingly delicate. The Italian Grand Prix offered perhaps the clearest illustration yet of that dynamic.
Monza turned Charles Leclerc’s talent into pressure
Starting third in front of the Tifosi with Lewis Hamilton immediately behind him presented Charles Leclerc with the perfect opportunity to make a major statement in his season. Instead, during the opening two laps, virtually everything happened that a Ferrari driver would ideally want to avoid during the team’s home Grand Prix.
Lewis Hamilton attacked down the inside at the first chicane. The two Ferrari cars ran alongside one another before the British driver ended up in the gravel, complaining over the radio that he had been forced off the circuit.
Charles Leclerc continued, but the next incident followed while he was under pressure. At Parabolica, while defending his position against Oscar Piastri, Charles Leclerc lost control of the Ferrari and crashed heavily into the barriers. Ferrari’s wider performance difficulties that afternoon were also evident in the SF-26 race analysis from Monza.
Charles Leclerc had turned an internal contest with Lewis Hamilton into an extremely aggressive situation at precisely the moment when he needed to demonstrate that he could control the circumstances and protect Ferrari’s interests.
While Ferrari still had both cars running, the confrontation between its drivers had already developed in a direction that could ultimately benefit only one of them: Lewis Hamilton.
Because Lewis Hamilton, despite being forced into the gravel, remained in the race. Charles Leclerc did not. While the Monegasque driver’s afternoon ended at Parabolica, Lewis Hamilton was at least able to bring Ferrari home in sixth place.
The aftermath also intensified the debate around the pair, even though Charles Leclerc subsequently rejected suggestions of a feud with Lewis Hamilton following their Monza battle.
Charles Leclerc needs to change his approach
This is where talent is no longer enough. Charles Leclerc has to understand that he cannot approach every difficult phase of his career with an all-or-nothing mentality.
He cannot expect every qualifying session to produce pole position, every Grand Prix to become a demonstration of strength and every internal battle to be a fight that has to be won at any cost. When Lewis Hamilton is sitting on the opposite side of the garage, every mistake carries twice the weight.
Lewis Hamilton knows how to turn a negative situation into an opportunity within the wider politics of a team. Monza provided another example. After being forced off at the first chicane, Lewis Hamilton immediately moved the discussion towards team management, internal rules and Ferrari’s responsibilities.
By the following day, the debate was no longer only about an incident between two drivers. It had become a discussion about Ferrari’s ability to manage its own line-up, an issue that has also fuelled wider questions over Ferrari’s team orders and Fred Vasseur’s handling of Lewis Hamilton and Charles Leclerc.
That is exactly the area in which Charles Leclerc still appears less effective. The Monegasque driver needs to leave Monza behind with a completely different attitude. He needs the strength to reset, step away from the intense media exposure for a while and rebuild from what happens on the circuit.
Charles Leclerc needs to become a genuine team leader. He needs to work for Ferrari rather than focusing only on his own result. He has to learn when an attack is necessary and when waiting is the more intelligent option. Above all, he needs to show that he can use his judgement even when the car is not capable of allowing him to perform miracles.
Talent must now become Ferrari leadership
A Formula 1 world champion is not simply a driver capable of finding two tenths of a second where others cannot see them. A champion is someone capable of turning those two tenths into points, those points into results and those results into a position of strength inside the team.
Charles Leclerc still possesses everything required to become a Formula 1 world champion. He has speed, talent, sensitivity and a level of qualifying performance that few drivers on the current grid can match.
But after eight seasons, being Ferrari’s great talent is no longer enough. Charles Leclerc needs to become Ferrari’s leader.
To achieve that, he will have to do something he has so far managed only intermittently: stop racing against everyone and start racing for something. Because the driver on the other side of the Ferrari garage is no longer simply another fast team-mate. It is Lewis Hamilton.
If Charles Leclerc continues to be drawn into an all-or-nothing battle, he risks discovering that the nickname Predestined can become a cage. It is a label built around his extraordinary talent, but without the maturity required to convert that talent into leadership, it risks remaining the description of a promise that was never completely fulfilled.
Leave a Reply