
On 3 July 2022, at the end of the British Grand Prix, Mattia Binotto pointed a finger at Charles Leclerc. The gesture lasted only a few seconds, captured by television cameras in the Silverstone parc fermé, but it triggered a wave of criticism directed at Ferrari’s then-team principal. Four years later, looking at what happened in Las Vegas, it is difficult not to wonder whether that pointed finger carried a message that many preferred to ignore at the time.
That afternoon, Carlos Sainz had secured his first Formula 1 victory, while Charles Leclerc, disadvantaged by a questionable Ferrari strategy during the Safety Car period, had lost a race he had appeared destined to win. The Monegasque was understandably furious. Mattia Binotto approached him before the interviews and, with a rather unmistakable gesture, appeared to be calling him to order.
The official explanation was quite different. “I told him he had driven a fantastic race and that he needed to look ahead, so he had to try to calm down,” Mattia Binotto told Sky Sport. Yet that image quickly became the symbol of a team principal accused of being unable to manage his most valuable talent. A team principal who, according to some, had even committed the unforgivable mistake of daring to reprimand Charles Leclerc.
Today, however, that scene perhaps deserves a different interpretation. What if Mattia Binotto had recognised something that would become increasingly apparent in the years that followed? What if that pointed finger also reflected the need to remind an extraordinarily fast driver that Ferrari must come before Charles Leclerc?
Was Mattia Binotto right about Charles Leclerc and Ferrari?
Because the problem has never been Charles Leclerc’s talent, which nobody should seriously question. The issue is how consistently that talent has been accompanied over the years by the ability to accept compromises, respect the chain of command and recognise when personal interests must give way to those of the team.
Between avoidable mistakes, increasingly intense battles with teammates and wasted opportunities, Charles Leclerc has often given the impression that every internal confrontation is something he must resolve in his own favour. There were already signs of tension with Sebastian Vettel, sparks flew with Carlos Sainz, and with Lewis Hamilton a fire has been ignited that cannot be extinguished without consequences.
And for a Ferrari team without a dominant car, turning every internal battle into a matter of principle risks throwing away championship points that are becoming increasingly valuable. The growing tensions between the current drivers have also raised concerns about the long-term consequences of the Lewis Hamilton and Charles Leclerc rivalry.
What should Fred Vasseur do after the Las Vegas collision?
Las Vegas took the problem to an extreme. On lap 38, Charles Leclerc attempted to overtake Lewis Hamilton, making contact and sending his teammate into a spin. The stewards held the Monegasque responsible for the incident and handed him a ten-second penalty. Lewis Hamilton finished seventh, while Charles Leclerc was tenth.
It was another result compromised by a collision between two drivers who, only a few weeks earlier, had already been reprimanded by their team principal following what happened in Mexico.
But this time there is an enormous aggravating factor. Fred Vasseur had issued clear instructions, and Charles Leclerc did not follow them. The Frenchman himself, furious after the race, confirmed this without attempting to offer any excuses.
“We told Charles not to overtake. He made a mistake that hurt the team. It’s unacceptable. After the Mexican Grand Prix, we had been extremely clear.”
Fred Vasseur then added even stronger words: “We have to do something and take action. You cannot ruin the work of so many people like this.”
And when discussing the relationship between the two drivers, the Ferrari team principal admitted that the situation had become “unmanageable”.
These words mark a breaking point. When a team principal publicly acknowledges that one of his drivers has ignored a direct instruction, the problem is no longer exclusively about what happens on the circuit. It becomes a question of authority, credibility and respect for the team’s hierarchy.
Fred Vasseur’s authority at Ferrari faces its biggest test
Fred Vasseur has already been accused too many times of being unable to assert his authority over his drivers. He has tried to give them freedom, attempted to manage tensions through dialogue and, after Mexico, firmly reiterated that the team must come before any individual’s interests.
Yet at the first real opportunity, those instructions were ignored once again.
At this point, what value can the team principal’s word carry if someone driving a Ferrari can independently decide to disregard it? And what credibility could Fred Vasseur retain in the eyes of his staff if, once again, everything were resolved with a meeting, a few predictable statements and a promise to move forward?
The question goes beyond the immediate disagreement between Charles Leclerc and Lewis Hamilton. It concerns the way Ferrari is managed and whether the authority of the team principal is genuinely recognised by those driving its cars.
What decision must Ferrari make about Charles Leclerc and Lewis Hamilton?
Ferrari must make a decision. Not necessarily about the immediate contractual futures of those involved, but certainly about responsibilities and the team’s command structure. Continuing like this would condemn the Scuderia to a state of permanent conflict and, quite possibly, leave it wondering in the future why it failed to take concrete action when it had the opportunity.
Ferrari chose to sign Lewis Hamilton, a seven-time world champion, with everything such a decision entails from a sporting, financial and media perspective. It was a move that should have strengthened the team. Instead, it has ended up exposing a management weakness that was already present during the Carlos Sainz era.
Lewis Hamilton certainly bears some responsibility for the tensions this season and has not been immune to mistakes. But in the decisive Las Vegas incident, it is difficult to place the greater share of the blame on him.
It was Charles Leclerc who attempted the overtake prohibited by the pit wall. It was Charles Leclerc who caused the contact, at a point where none of the other 127 overtakes had been attempted. And it was Charles Leclerc who received the penalty.
Above all, it is worth repeating that Charles Leclerc had been instructed not to attack his teammate, let alone at that particular point on the circuit and with those risks involved.
The incident also adds another dimension to the 2026 Las Vegas Grand Prix and Ferrari’s competitive ambitions, with the team’s internal disagreements once again affecting its ability to maximise a race result.
Charles Leclerc’s talent cannot excuse every Ferrari mistake
It is possible to continue defending Charles Leclerc because of his talent, his speed over a single qualifying lap and his ability to achieve results that often exceed the potential of the car. These are genuine qualities.
But talent does not guarantee immunity from consequences, particularly when mistakes compromise the work of hundreds of people and the team’s overall result.
Ferrari could have collected considerably more points throughout this season, despite all the technical limitations of the SF-26. Naturally, not every missed opportunity can be attributed to Charles Leclerc. However, it would be equally wrong to continue treating his mistakes and excesses as unavoidable consequences of an intensely competitive mentality.
The season-long performances of the two Ferrari drivers can also be examined through the Charles Leclerc versus Lewis Hamilton head-to-head statistics, which compare their qualifying results, race performances and championship records.
Could Ferrari be forced to reconsider its driver line-up?
Fred Vasseur now faces a decision that could also determine his own future. Either he succeeds in restoring authority that is recognised and respected by both drivers, with concrete consequences for anyone who disobeys team orders, or the current balance within Ferrari will inevitably have to be questioned.
And if the relationship between Charles Leclerc and Lewis Hamilton ultimately proves impossible to repair, Maranello should have the courage to reconsider its driver line-up as well, without treating anyone as untouchable.
Four years ago, Mattia Binotto was heavily criticised for pointing a finger at Charles Leclerc. Today, Fred Vasseur, having issued an instruction that was ignored on track, is openly discussing disciplinary action.
Mattia Binotto left Ferrari just a few months after Silverstone. Fred Vasseur now risks watching his own authority erode in front of the television cameras.
Perhaps it is time to revisit that old image from 2022. Not to vindicate every decision Mattia Binotto made, because he made plenty of mistakes, but to remember that a team principal must be able to exercise authority.
Even when the driver on the other side is Charles Leclerc.






Leave a Reply