Scuderia Fans

  • News
  • Current Drivers
    • Charles Leclerc
    • Lewis Hamilton
  • Races
    • 2026 F1 Bahrain Grand Prix
    • 2026 F1 Singapore Grand Prix
    • 2026 F1 United States Grand Prix
    • 2026 F1 Mexico City Grand Prix
    • 2026 F1 São Paulo Grand Prix
    • 2026 F1 Las Vegas Grand Prix
    • 2026 F1 Qatar Grand Prix
    • 2026 F1 Abu Dhabi Grand Prix
  • Formula 1 Statistics
  • Ferrari F1 World Champions
    • Michael Schumacher
    • Kimi Raikkonen
    • Niki Lauda
    • Jody Scheckter
    • John Surtees
    • Phil Hill
    • Mike Hawthorn
    • Juan-Manuel Fangio
    • Alberto Ascari
  • Former Ferrari drivers
    • Sebastian Vettel
    • Felipe Massa
    • Fernando Alonso
    • Gilles Villeneuve
    • Jean Alesi
    • Alain Prost
    • Nigel Mansell
    • Gerhard Berger
    • Mario Andretti
    • Rubens Barrichello
    • Michele Alboreto
    • Patrick Tambay
    • Eddie Irvine
    • Rene Arnoux
    • Didier Pironi
    • Jacky Ickx
    • Carlos Reutemann
    • Clay Regazzoni
    • Stefan Johansson
    • Arturo Merzario
    • Giancarlo Fisichella
    • Carlos Sainz
  • Ferrari WEC
  • F1 TICKETS
  • Advertise with ScuderiaFans
  • Ferrari F1 Shop
  • Home
  • Formula 1 Schedule & Results
  • Formula 1 Driver Standings
  • Formula 1 Constructor Standings
  • Contact us
Home » FIA Double Standards on Penalties: An Explanation by a Steward

FIA Double Standards on Penalties: An Explanation by a Steward. Johnny Herbert attempted to provide an explanation for the inconsistency in the FIA stewards' decisions .

2024 F1 race start, McLaren, Oscar Piastri

The rotation of stewards and the inconsistency in judgment when assigning penalties has been a longstanding issue in Formula 1.

Given the many, perhaps too many, similar incidents that are often judged differently from one race to another, many have called for the appointment of a single panel of stewards to assess situations during Grands Prix. However, this proposal has never been seriously considered.

So why continue with the rotation, fueling ongoing controversies, instead of appointing four permanent stewards for every race of the season?

According to Johnny Herbert, who served as a steward at several events this year, one of the reasons may be economic: “Should there be a commissioner for every single race? Can this or all four be debated in the same way? Yes, it can be discussed,” the former driver told PlanetF1.

Add ScuderiaFans.com as your preferred Google News source for Formula 1 updates

“But it’s a matter of time. We don’t get paid much for this. We earn $300 a day or something like that, so it’s very little.”

“At that point, it turns into a real job, where you commit to a season, for 20 or more races, for example. So, it’s very, very different from this point of view.”

Despite Toto Wolff harshly criticizing the stewards after the penalty received by George Russell, Johnny Herbert does not believe the decision-making process differs significantly despite the rotations: “Every time I sat with the other stewards, we all had a very similar mindset.”

Ferrari F1 merchandise

“I think that’s why consistency seems to be the best overall, and it’s difficult to try to put together the right ingredients to maintain it.”

“We all come from very different places. Two of us are English, but there’s also a Brazilian and an Italian. We all have different ways, sometimes, of dealing with certain situations. It seems we have a calm workforce that works very, very well.”

“A driver will always have his opinion, and so will the teams. Everyone comes in with their own thoughts and explanations about what’s happening. That’s where we have to try to figure out what’s going on. Sometimes it’s not easy, sometimes it seems tough, but then fairness and consistency must come into play at the same time.”

“Every time you try to fit everything into a certain incident, it becomes a sort of category, but they’re not all the same within that category because they’re all different. Every weekend there’s something different, and that’s why the situation has become more consistent. We all seem to be on the same wavelength, and that’s something that works very well at the moment.”

Dec 29, 2024Luca Marini
Click here to set ScuderiaFans.com as your preferred Google Discover source and find our content more easily!
F1 2025 calendar with all dates: here's when the action will returnFerrari SF-24: key foundational elements essential for aiming higher in 2025

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Luca Marini

Luca Marini is a ScuderiaFans editorial byline covering Ferrari’s technical developments, car upgrades and Formula 1 regulations. His articles explain how these changes may influence performance on track.

1 year ago News2024 Formula 1 season163
Next F1 race
0 Days
00 Hours
00 Mins
00 Secs
RACE DAY
until lights out
Gear up with Ferrari merchandise!
Buy official Ferrari 2026 F1 products
2026 Formula 1 calendar

Complete 2026 Formula 1 calendar with all Grand Prix dates and locations

Latest Ferrari technical analysis
Ferrari F1 power unit, engine
Ferrari’s 2027 F1 engine gains: why 10, 20 or 30 extra horsepower remains speculation
4 hours ago
Charles Leclerc, Ferrari SF-26, 2026 F1
Ferrari 2027 car development: The aerodynamic lesson from Sebastian Vettel and Adrian Newey
2 days ago
Lewis Hamilton, Ferrari SF-26, garage, sidepods, 2026 F1
Why Ferrari struggled at Interlagos: Three technical problems behind its Brazilian GP collapse
3 days ago
Charles Leclerc, Ferrari SF26, 2026 F1, wet
Ferrari’s wet-weather struggles in 2026: Why the SF-26 is improving despite Brazilian GP setback
3 days ago
Max Verstappen (Red Bull RB22), Charles Leclerc (Ferrari), 2026 F1
Ferrari’s new engine fails to solve problems: SF-26 loses up to 1.4 seconds per lap in Brazil
4 days ago

Latest articles

  • Former Ferrari driver reveals how Luca di Montezemolo ruled Maranello and sends message over Fred Vasseur
  • Ferrari junior Rafael Camara impresses with remarkable speed on difficult Haas F1 debut in Brazil
  • Why Ralf Schumacher keeps bringing Michael Schumacher into the Lewis Hamilton debate
  • Ferrari faces major Las Vegas GP challenge as SF-26 engine weakness threatens another difficult weekend
  • Ferrari’s 2027 F1 engine gains: why 10, 20 or 30 extra horsepower remains speculation
Partners
Betwinner

non-GamStop casinos

best online casinos not on GamStop

bwacademy

magyarkaszinooldalak

GP-News - latest F1 news updates

The most accurate sports predictions and latest news available on TipsGG

1Win

no deposit casinos at GHZD Betpack Mostbet Pakistan top canadian casinos

Formula 1 News

Guitar Junky

Best Intraday Tips

Contact Center Company

SilverArrows.Net - Mercedes F1 news

TopSpeed

Esports Forum

Racing Statistics

Fixture Calendar

Live F1 Results

You can find reel-based games without download or registration via free slots on Slotozilla

Uusia Nettikasinoita
Thailand Walking Street

de bedste odds uden ROFUS på Leadership.ng

Get In Touch With Us

  • Advertise with ScuderiaFans
  • Contact us
  • Corrections Policy
  • Editorial Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Support ScuderiaFans.com

Meet the team

  • About us
  • Our writers
  • Formula 1 Circuits
  • 2026 Formula 1 Calendar
  • Formula 1 Statistics & Analysis
  • Ferrari F1 FAQ

© 2016–2026 Scuderia Fans Ltd. All rights reserved.

Scuderia Fans Ltd.
199 Republicii Street, 5A
Ploiesti, Romania, 100392
2016 © Scuderia Fans