Public comments made by Dr Isabel Ornaque about Charles Leclerc’s behaviour during post-crash medical examinations have triggered criticism among Formula 1 fans, particularly after the doctor speculated about Asperger’s while describing the Ferrari driver’s reaction to an earlier accident.
Ornaque, who is responsible for Formula 1 medical services in Madrid and Barcelona, made the remarks during the Forum Internacional CEMTRO in Madrid on 7 September, one day after Charles Leclerc suffered a 23G impact at Monza. While discussing the process of assessing a driver after a major accident, she also gave details of her encounter with Leclerc following his 22G qualifying crash at the Circuit de Barcelona-Catalunya earlier this season.
Charles Leclerc doctor comments focus on Barcelona assessment
Ornaque explained that Charles Leclerc had initially been extremely quiet when he arrived for examination after the Barcelona accident. She said his vital signs were fine and that his neurological examination did not reveal anything abnormal, but described difficulty establishing communication with him during the early part of the assessment.
While recounting that episode, Ornaque questioned whether Leclerc’s silence was the result of concussion, simply part of his personality or whether there could be another explanation. At one point she asked whether he was concussed or had “a little bit of Asperger’s”, before describing him as “just a bit weird like that”.
She said Leclerc remained with the medical team for around 45 minutes before gradually beginning to ask for his watch and clothes and questioning why someone from Ferrari had not arrived to collect him. According to Ornaque’s account, his medical observations remained normal and he was subsequently allowed to leave.
Why the remarks about Charles Leclerc caused criticism
The comments prompted a strong reaction online, with criticism centred on both the tone of the discussion and the decision to recount details of an individual driver’s medical assessment in a public setting. Some fans described the remarks as disrespectful and unprofessional, while others questioned whether discussing Leclerc’s behaviour and examination in that level of detail was compatible with medical confidentiality.
It is important, however, to distinguish those accusations from an established breach. There is currently no public information demonstrating whether Charles Leclerc consented to any of the information being discussed, or whether a particular confidentiality rule was formally violated. The available material therefore does not justify presenting a breach of medical confidentiality as a confirmed fact.
There is also no evidence that Charles Leclerc has been diagnosed with Asperger’s syndrome, autism or any related condition, and Ornaque did not present her remark as a diagnosis. In modern clinical classification, Asperger’s disorder is no longer a separate diagnosis under the DSM-5, having been incorporated into the broader autism spectrum disorder category when the manual was revised in 2013.
Charles Leclerc cleared to return for Spanish GP
The controversy has emerged against the backdrop of another substantial accident for the Ferrari driver. Charles Leclerc hit the barriers at Monza’s Parabolica in a 23G impact and subsequently underwent further medical checks before travelling to Madrid.
Leclerc was ultimately cleared to compete at the new Madring circuit and returned to normal Formula 1 action during the Spanish Grand Prix weekend. He reached Q3 on Saturday and qualified fifth, directly behind Ferrari team-mate Lewis Hamilton in fourth.
The medical outcome is therefore separate from the debate surrounding Ornaque’s public remarks. Charles Leclerc has returned to competition, while the criticism concerns the way aspects of his previous medical assessments and personality were discussed outside the examination room. At the time of writing, no public response specifically addressing that backlash has been identified from Ferrari, the FIA or Ornaque herself.
Leave a Reply