Crash gate, a clear conspiracy: Felipe Massa’s struggle and Ferrari’s deafening silence. Crash gate, a clear conspiracy.

Certain wounds struggle to heal. Felipe Massa knows this all too well, a driver capable of recovering from the terrible accident he suffered during the 2009 Hungarian Grand Prix, but whose pride still can’t “digest” an injustice that has become so glaring it almost takes on a farcical tone. We are clearly referring to the night of the “race of shame,” the infamous Singapore 2008 or the “crash gate.” Recent statements, later retracted, by Bernie Ecclestone have added fuel to the fire of one of the darkest chapters in Formula 1 history.

The article retraces the significant events that have marked the scandal over the last 15 years. The matter is causing great discomfort within the FIA and F1, and at this point, nothing is ruled out. Amidst all this, the resounding silence of Ferrari, potentially defrauded of the 2008 drivers’ title, hurts those who believe in the values of sportsmanship and the fate of the Prancing Horse.

Scuderia Ferrari as the Injured Party: Unjustifiable Absence

In hindsight, Scuderia Ferrari’s stance since the FIA’s verdict that condemned Flavio Briatore and Pat Symonds appears rather peculiar. Aside from Felipe, the historic Modena-based team also paid the sporting price for the missed sixteenth world championship. Their passive attitude in the face of an evident sports fraud is perplexing. It’s important to remember that in 2008, Stefano Domenicali had just taken over the racing department of the Prancing Horse, succeeding the more experienced and politically influential Jean Todt. The same applies to Ross Brawn, who had left Maranello in October 2006. Furthermore, Formula 1 could not afford another scandal after the 2007 Spygate, a historical moment when the category was at its lowest credibility. When Nelson Piquet uncovered the Pandora’s Box, the Concorde Agreement for 2009-2012 had just been signed – an agreement between the F1 commercial rights holders and the teams participating in the championship. The agreement ended months of tension and controversy between the organization led by Max Mosley and the teams. In the subsequent agreement signed in 2012, Scuderia Ferrari was granted a $50 million bonus regardless of their position in the championship. It’s likely that the historic Italian team was strongly advised not to unleash a new uproar with the promise of greater financial benefits over the long term and the reintroduction of the right of veto. Ferrari’s silence on the dirty affair of Singapore, without any kind of support for Felipe Massa’s claims, is quite baffling.

2008 Singapore Grand Prix

During the formation lap, Nelson Piquet Jr. spun at Turn 17 in his Renault. The sequence of events was odd, but the Brazilian driver managed to rejoin the starting grid. His teammate, Fernando Alonso, had a great start due to very little fuel on board. However, by the twelfth lap, Alonso was called into the pits for refueling. He rejoined the race as the last car on the track.

Fortune seemed to favor Fernando Alonso because two laps later, Nelson Piquet lost control of his Renault R28, again at Turn 17, and crashed into the barriers. This triggered the safety car and provided an incredible assist to his teammate, who unexpectedly won the race ahead of Nico Rosberg and Lewis Hamilton. The Ferrari pit crew made a catastrophic mistake during Felipe Massa’s pit stop, releasing the Brazilian driver before refueling was complete.

2009 Hungarian Grand Prix

After an uninspiring season, Nelsinho Piquet was ousted from Renault following the Hungarian Grand Prix, a fact confirmed by the Brazilian driver on August 3, 2009. It’s rather peculiar to note that pivotal moments in Felipe Massa’s career are linked to those of his compatriots. In the qualifying session of the Hungarian Grand Prix, Massa was struck by a component from Barrichello’s BrawnGP car, losing consciousness and crashing into the barriers at Turn 4, effectively ending his race in the Ferrari F60.

On August 30, 2009, Brazilian TV station “TV Globo” announced that Nelson Piquet Jr. had intentionally caused a crash during the 2008 Singapore Grand Prix to benefit his teammate, Fernando Alonso. On September 4 of the same year, the FIA formally accused the Renault team of manipulating the race outcome.

The FIA Verdict

On September 21, 2009, the FIA issued severe sporting penalties for Flavio Briatore and Pat Symonds: a lifetime ban for the Piedmontese manager and a five-year ban for the British engineer. Any involvement of Fernando Alonso was excluded.

The “Reversal” by the Tribunal de Grande Instance in Paris

On January 5, 2010, the Tribunal de Grande Instance in Paris declared the decision made by the FIA World Motor Sport Council to ban Flavio Briatore “irregular,” and ordered the FIA to communicate Briatore’s reinstatement. As for Briatore’s request for compensation of one million euros for damages to his image, the Paris TGI set the compensation for the former Renault Team Principal at 15,000 euros.

Bernie Ecclestone’s Confession

On March 1, 2023, F1Insider published a detailed and explosive statement by Bernie Ecclestone regarding the Crash Gate.

The former Formula 1 boss candidly spilled the beans, stating, “Max Mosley (former FIA president) and I were informed during the 2008 season about what had happened in the Singapore race. Piquet Jr. had told his father Nelson that the team asked him to crash into the wall to trigger a safety car period to help his teammate Alonso. We decided not to do anything. We wanted to protect the sport and save it from a huge scandal. That’s why I convinced my former driver Nelson Piquet to keep quiet. We had enough information in time to investigate the matter. According to the regulations, under these circumstances, we should have canceled the Singapore race. Felipe Massa would have become world champion, not Lewis Hamilton.”

Felipe Massa’s Legal Action Begins

Bernie Ecclestone’s statement aligns with Felipe Massa’s argument that he fell victim to a conspiracy. In mid-August, the London law firm Enyo Law sent a formal eight-page letter, a sort of pre-litigation notice, to Formula 1 President Stefano Domenicali and FIA President Mohammed Ben Sulayem. The contents of the letter state, “Mr. Massa has been the victim of a conspiracy committed by individuals at the highest levels of F1, FIA, and FOM. In short, Mr. Massa is the legitimate 2008 drivers’ champion, and F1 and the FIA have deliberately ignored the misconduct that deprived him of the title. Mr. Massa is unable to fully quantify his losses at this stage, but estimates they may exceed tens of millions of euros; this amount does not cover the serious moral and reputational losses suffered by Mr. Massa.”

Bernie’s “Amnesia”

On August 18, 2023, Bernie Ecclestone, contacted by Reuters news agency, retracted his statements, claiming not to remember anything about his remarks